Example 1 · Deduction
Every student in Group P has completed a diagnostic test. Nora is a student in Group P. Which statement must be true?
- A.Nora had the highest score
- B.Only Group P students completed the test
- C.Nora completed a diagnostic test
- D.Nora completed every available test
- E.Every student who completed the test is in Group P
Show answer and worked explanation
Answer C: Nora completed a diagnostic test
The rule applies to every member of Group P, and Nora is a member. Therefore Nora completed a diagnostic test.
The premises say nothing about scores, other tests, or who else completed the diagnostic. The final option reverses the original implication.
